Repair vs. Replacement

When evaluating whether a damaged facility is eligible for replacement, FEMA compares the repair cost with the replacement cost and evaluates the feasibility of repairing the facility.

A facility is considered repairable when:

  • The cost to repair the disaster-related damage does not exceed 50 percent of the cost to replace the facility based on its pre-disaster size, capacity, and function; and
  • It is feasible to repair the facility so that it can perform the pre-disaster function as well as it did prior to the incident

The comparison of the repair cost to the replacement cost results in a fraction that expresses repair as a percentage of replacement. The percentage is calculated with the repair cost as the numerator and the replacement costs as the denominator. FEMA refers to this calculation as the "50% Rule."